Saturday, September 15, 2012

Chapter 11: Post 1

The role of a mediator is well-suited for a communication studies majors because it applies the theories and techniques in a real world setting. In my personal experience as communication studies major, I've been introduced to the role of a facilitator and worked with a group of students as a class project. The rules that were taught to me then are very similar to what the textbook teaches as rules for a mediator. Similar ideas are used, like neutrality and re-framing are vital to both. These concepts are being taught to communication studies major every year, which is why it is a great stepping stone into mediation. Communication studies majors should make great mediators because they've not only learned these skills, but they've had the chance to use them and improve on them. With more training for formal contexts, a communication studies major would do an excellent job in the realm of mediation.
Lawyers and psychotherapists might find it difficult to play the role of a mediator due to its necessity of neutrality. A mediator must be an unbiased, third party. He or she must not side with either party, nor use any authority. Since lawyers and psychotherapists play authoritative figures, they may have trouble keeping opinion to themselves. Their jobs are to give advice, therefore mediation would not be the best role for them. A mediator should not make any decision making. He or she needs to speak only for his or herself. Someone who has been well-trained to use his authority to make a decision, like a lawyer, would not be the best fit for mediation.

1 Comments:

At September 16, 2012 at 7:16 PM , Blogger JD Anthony said...

Mediation and communication majors go hand in hand. Like you, I have been involved in a project where I was a facilitator, and it was a both a challenge and good time partaking in it. I also see a lot of familiarities with facilitation and mediation since both of them involve similar concepts. Comm majors are being taught to be effective communicators in society and that is the main thing a mediator needs to be good at. They have to be able to talk at the right time, actively listen and facilitate discussion.

I agree with your assessments of why lawyers and psychotherapists wouldn’t make good mediators. Lawyers are taught how to be persuasive, cunning and are usually very intelligent so can use their skills to get what they want. It would be hard for them to take a backseat and let a mediation happen with their mind whirring with what is right and wrong with the situation. Likewise, a psychotherapist would want to help the problem and may not be able to be completely biased with their approach to what they think the best solution would be.

Good job, Julianne!

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home